Spoon out yolks into a bowl keeping egg whites in tact. Set them aside.
Mix in remaining ingredients, except paprika, until smooth.
Spoon or pipe mixture into egg whites.
Sprinkle with paprika and refrigerate or serve immediately.
Notes
To pipe in the mixture, spoon into a zip-top bag. Move mixture down, remove excess air, and seal. Snip 1/4" corner of the bag and proceed to pipe it in!